David Cameron is potentially making a serious mistake in Ayr today.
Amongst the rhetoric on wanting to govern the whole UK is the implied offering up of English interests to be sacrificed to buy off other parts of the UK.
This won't work on two levels:
1) Justice for England: He is reported by the BBC as follows:
Mr Cameron said he was confident of bringing in a system where English MPs had a decisive say when the Commons was voting on an issue affecting English constituencies. But he argued: "Better an imperfect Union than a broken one. Better an imperfect Union than a perfect divorce. My answer is simple. I choose the United Kingdom."
This just won't do for the English. The imperfect bit - is the bit where English interests get sold out ( that's what an imperfect Union means). I'm afraid his choice of words on English issues just doesn't wash.
2)
Equality of respect and self worth for all the UKIn the end the lack of balance will eat away at the self respect of the Welsh and Scots. They will have semi-detached status, which is just the waiting room for full separation. ( I suspect the Northern Irish case is different ).
A lack of symmetry between the parts of the UK is just going to put the Union in a permanent game of Russian roulette with nationalism in the same way that Canada can never resolve its Quebec problem. The SNP and maybe Plaid will always seek referendums (regardless of the results of previous ones ) until they achieve their ends - and the semi detached nature of Scotland and Wales will just encourage the idea its inevitable.
Why not a perfect Union Mr Cameron, with an English Executive and Parliament ? In the end it is the only way to save the Union - everything else just delays its destruction.
We need a stable and just Union based on equality of respect for the home nations, fairness and friendship.